How to find the right watch strap?

There’s a wooden watch box in my study. Every morning, after I’ve had my first cup of coffee, I walk over to it, open the lid, and choose a watch for the day. As I do so, I pause to think: What am I going to wear today? What’s the main color, and what accents will I add? That’s exactly what I look for when choosing the right watch. These five minutes are one of the main reasons why I collect watches. For me, it’s a lovely, mindful moment in which I set the tone for the day—a tone that stays with me throughout.

Most of the time, it doesn’t stop at just the watch—very often, my next step is to immediately think about the right strap. Many of my watches have a 20-mm lug width, and only if a watch really wins me over do I buy one with a different size. The big advantage is that I can mix and match almost all my watch straps across all my watches.

“Clothes make the man,” as the saying goes. Perhaps this was even more true in the past than it is today, but we still associate certain moods with specific clothing. Things are much less formal today, and many rules set in stone have long since been creatively reimagined. But when we hear that saying, a certain image immediately comes to mind.

It’s exactly the same with watches. In many ways, the strap contributes to a watch’s overall appeal—sometimes even more so than the dial or the shape of the case. That’s why today I’d like to take a very close look at how different straps, colors, and materials affect a watch.

Knud Andresen, one of the founders of Strapklub, was kind enough to lend me a colorful selection of straps for this review. Strapklub is a new player on the market and combines German craftsmanship, top-quality materials, and reasonable prices. You can tell that right away when you pick up the straps.

Over the years, I’ve ordered straps from God knows where—a few really great finds, but mostly a whole lot of junk. The Strapklub straps, which I’ve had the chance to try out on countless watches over the past few days, feel really good right from the start. Of course, not every color option is my personal favorite, but that’s exactly the point: trying things out, experimenting, and discovering what’s possible.

And that’s exactly what this article is meant to inspire you to do. I know way too many watch enthusiasts who wouldn’t even think of changing the strap on their favorite watch. They wear the strap that came with the watch straight from the factory. That usually works out just fine, since the brands definitely put a lot of thought into the design. But a watch isn’t always used exactly as the designer envisioned it on the drawing board—and that’s perfectly fine. Because in the end, what matters is: if you like it, it’s good.


Why do I change my straps so often, anyway?

I own a few watches that are known as “strap monsters.” They look really good with almost any strap, and I like to match them to my outfit. My Nomos Minimatik, my DUG Purist, and my Junghans Max Bill are all white, neutral watches that go with any color. That’s why I sometimes wear them with a black, brown, colorful, gray, or beige strap. Most of the time, I match the strap to the main color of my outfit, but sometimes I just pick up on an accent from my belt, scarf, or shoes. Tone-on-tone or a wild mix.

With certain watches, I like to switch between stainless steel and leather straps, or use a rubber strap for swimming. However, I’m not a big fan of rubber on my wrist. That’s why I was especially keen on a few straps from Strapklub—you can go in the water with them without any problems, since they aren’t glued. Leather doesn’t like water, but more importantly, a lot of watch straps are glued. When you swim, the glue dissolves over time and the strap falls apart.

But let’s dive right in and start with one of my most versatile watches. The Nomos Minimatik 39 is simple and classic, with small but elegant gold accents.


The Nomos Minimatik 39 looks great in any color

Of course, you can wear a classic white watch with a brown or black strap. I do that quite often (though not together as shown in the photo—there you can clearly see the warm versus cool classic looks). But the watch also looks great with dark green or the very modern ice blue. The Alcantara model in particular—which comes not only in this gorgeous blue but also in a super-soft and fluffy version—has a sporty vibe without losing any of its dress watch charm. Pair it with chinos and a linen shirt—and bring on summer. The dark green also pairs perfectly with all Barbour colors, any English country house style, or—as in my case—a green or brown oversized sweater. This way, the watch adds a touch of contrast to the sporty outfit, which I love. Above all, it shows that even a classic dress watch can be adapted with different straps without altering the watch’s character.


Traska Venturer GMT with a dark meteorite dial

Let’s now move on to a completely different watch: the Traska Venturer GMT with a dark meteorite dial. We’ll see that the same watch straps won’t work here, since the watch is very dark. But the watch also takes on a completely different look with different straps.

A black or anthracite-colored strap is, of course, a natural choice for this dial. Unlike with the Nomos, however, I find the textile strap more suitable here than the black cowhide leather. The textured grain of the cowhide leather doesn’t quite match the sportiness of the Traska. Since both the textile strap and the blue Alcantara are suitable for swimming, they also pair very well with this Gadamer watch. And once again, the ice blue has won me over. While it made the Nomos look sportier, it softens the Traska’s ruggedness a bit and gives it a more playful feel, which I really like.

I also tried the two brown straps, but I didn’t really like that combination. Not because I was thinking about the rule that you shouldn’t mix black and brown, but because the Traska isn’t actually true black. The gray meteorite dial, however, looks really good in contrast to the orange cowhide leather, and I think the textured grain works well, too. I also noticed that the GMT arrow has a red-orange outline, which makes the combination even better.

What’s more important to me, though, is to show that even a black or gray watch that comes with a dark or stainless steel strap doesn’t have to be stuck in a perpetually dark existence—it’s just as well-suited as a white watch to take on a new character with contrasting colors. Especially in the summer, the dark version would be too boring for me. In the winter, when Berlin is gray for months on end, ice blue or orange can of course add a splash of color. But I’m also very happy with black or anthracite.


Side Note: What are the StrapKlub wristbands like to wear?

Appearance is certainly important, but I think comfort is even more important when it comes to watches. If I don’t like a watch, I won’t even try it on my wrist. But no matter how beautiful I think it is, if it doesn’t fit right, I won’t wear or buy it.

One example is the Longines Hydroconquest. I was absolutely thrilled with the watch, but as soon as I put it on my wrist, I knew I’d never want to wear it for a whole day. An even better example is my Kowa Royal Smith. At 35 mm, this watch is significantly smaller than all my other watches. With the brown leather strap it came with, it would either slide up to the top of my wrist or cut off my circulation. It was so uncomfortable to wear that I eventually gave it to my partner. But she recently ordered a new strap that looks very similar to the black cowhide from Strapklub. We put it on the watch, and it’s fit me perfectly ever since. I actually think it looks better with a black strap than with a brown one.

So comfort is important. That’s why it’s not just the color, design, or grain that matter, but also how it feels to you. At the end of each leather section, I’ve also included a link to Strapklub. You’ll find even more information there. Knud is truly a walking encyclopedia of materials and, above all, offers many more colors. If I’d tested them all, this article certainly wouldn’t have been published this year.

Cordovan: Horse leather is one of the most durable and sturdy types of leather—and you can really feel that on your wrist. It’s really stiff at first and not as supple as other types of leather, but that changes quickly. Once it breaks in, it fits perfectly and feels like a second skin. Cordovan is my favorite, especially for watches that you wear a lot in everyday life and that therefore need to be able to hold up to some wear and tear. Just don’t go swimming with it on. The Strapklub strap looks higher-quality than the Cordovan one I already own. It’s hand-stitched, which I think is important, because even durable leather is no good if the seams eventually come apart. 🔗 Strapklub

Alcantara: The material is so darn fluffy and soft—I love it! I already own one, and I’m so thrilled with the ice-blue model that it definitely won’t be my last. The material gives every watch a modern look—even in beige or black—and is incredibly comfortable. I highly recommend everyone try it for themselves. I’m sure you’ll love it just as much as I do. It looks like suede, but it’s vegan. The funny thing is that it was originally designed for car manufacturing and is used in high-end models for seats and upholstery. Since it’s made of plastic, it’s also suitable for swimming and is softer than suede. 🔗 Strapklub

Novonappa: I was most excited about the strap. The leather is exceptionally high-quality and, as far as I know, comes from the same manufacturer as Hermès’ leather. You can tell that right away when you touch it. The Novonappa calfskin is very soft and molds instantly to the wrist. It’s also really nice and flat, which makes it a great fit for smaller watches that would get lost visually under a thick strap. I also really like the very fine grain. It gives the strap texture without being as bold as, say, alligator leather. It’s with a heavy heart that I’ll be returning this strap to Knud. 🔗 Auf der Webseite des Strapklub.

Calfskin: Calfskin is naturally supple and becomes even more supple over time. It’s soft and smooth, which is why it’s so often used as the inner lining for watch straps. The surface is very smooth, so the strap is unobtrusive and doesn’t steal the show from the watch—unless, of course, you choose a contrasting color, in which case it certainly will. Personally, I find calfskin a bit boring, but there are watches that need exactly that. It’s a shame my Angles hasn’t arrived for the test yet—that would be a watch that needs a very understated strap. 🔗 Strapklub.

Cowhide: Cowhide leather is also stiff at first and takes some time to soften. However, it’s significantly softer than Cordovan, for example, and the softer calfskin on the underside ensures that it feels very gentle against the skin of the wrist right from the start. I also like the leather’s subtle grain. I think it gives every watch a vintage look and makes it cooler. Even a completely black strap catches so much light because of the grain that it never looks entirely black. If that’s important to you, calfskin, lambskin, or pigskin are better options. 🔗 Strapklub.

Textile strap: The textile strap is made from recycled plastic and is therefore slightly rougher. This makes it very durable and waterproof, but of course not as comfortable to wear as leather straps. However, cowhide leather is sewn into the lining, which is just as waterproof and feels significantly softer. Thanks to this combination, the textile strap feels comfortable on the wrist. I don’t know how much more flexible it will become over time, but the strap is very pliable right from the start and therefore fits very well around the wrist. I definitely want one for my dive watches and think it’s so much better than any NATO strap. I don’t like the bulge of fabric that always forms unless you have a huge wrist circumference.🔗 Strapklub.

For the future, I have just two and a half requests: First, the ability to choose the clasp color and material, and second, three sizes that can be ordered at no additional cost.

Currently, all clasps are semi-matte and made of stainless steel. However, for a gold watch, I’d like a gold clasp, and for a shiny watch, a polished stainless steel clasp. Of course, I can adapt the original clasp from my watch to fit the Strapklub strap, but that doesn’t always work because the Strapklub clasp is typically 16 mm, while the lug width is 20 mm. However, I have a few watches where the clasp is 18 mm, even though the lug width is 20 mm. In that case, it doesn’t fit. Many suppliers allow you to choose the color of the clasp for a small additional fee.

At 16.5 cm, my wrist is slightly smaller than average, so I find shorter watchbands much more comfortable because I don’t constantly get the end caught on things. Standard watchbands are usually 120/80 mm long, but fortunately, Strapklub’s are a bit shorter at 114/72 mm. However, some manufacturers offer both a larger and a smaller size (unfortunately, not for all straps). This is more comfortable for me, but essential for my partner, since standard lengths don’t fit her at all. I hope that as Strapklub grows, both sizes will eventually be available. But this really only affects people with smaller or extremely large wrists and shouldn’t matter at all to most people.


Omega CK 859: Classic or Cool?

At first glance, my Omega CK859 from the Museum Collection resembles the Nomos. Upon closer inspection, however, you’ll notice some differences. The Omega’s dial isn’t white—it’s actually made of genuine 925 sterling silver. As a result, it appears white in sunlight and steel gray by candlelight. A great effect! This makes the watch look older or more refined than the Nomos, even though both are classic dress watches. This also affects the straps. The watch came with a cognac-colored calfskin strap, which isn’t unlike the Novonappa strap from Strapklub shown in the first picture. The color is a good match, but I never wore the watch with the original strap. The leather was too stiff, the strap was too long, and the color is lighter than in the photo. As a result, the watch didn’t look quite right to me, so I switched to a dark brown suede strap.

While playing around with the Strapklub straps, however, I noticed that green, ice blue, or the sportier black textile strap don’t go well with the Omega. But Knud gave me the orange cowhide leather strap specifically for this watch. I thought he was a little crazy at the time, but he was right: the orange looks really cool in contrast to the silver and, above all, the blue hands. I do tend to favor the classic colors of brown and black, but seeing that even the Omega can look very modern and cool with an orange contrast has confirmed my basic theory. Every watch has a strap that suits it and at least one contrasting color that makes it look really cool.


Diver’s watches also look great on a strap: Seiko SNE571

There’s one more rule: Diver’s watches must only be worn on a stainless steel bracelet. On the one hand, this makes sense, since leather straps fall apart when you swim or dive with them. On the other hand, most diver’s watches have probably seen more screen light than actual sunlight—let alone actual dives. There’s even a term for this that I find funny: “desk diver,” meaning a diver’s watch that stays on your desk. So I couldn’t care less about the rule, because I think my Seiko looks so much nicer on a fabric or leather strap. I didn’t even adjust the included stainless steel bracelet to fit my wrist—I just took it off right away. But I rarely wear the watch at my desk; I actually bought it for swimming. That’s why I first tried out the water-resistant straps from Strapklub.

The textile strap and the Alcantara strap are wonderfully suited for swimming, and both look really good. The black textile strap matches the watch perfectly—its dial varies between almost black and coffee brown depending on the light. And the ice-blue Alcantara also looks extremely fitting. While it almost changes the character of the Nomos and the Traska, on the Seiko it harmonizes with the gray-brown bezel and underscores the sporty character of the diver’s watch. Both materials also feel really good, and I’m not quite sure whether I prefer textile or Alcantara. When swimming, fabric probably offers more grip and dries faster, but Alcantara is so soft and supple for everything else.

Unfortunately, the Novonappa isn’t suitable for swimming, but its warm brown color makes it a perfect match for the watch. If I weren’t going to use the watch for swimming, this would definitely be my first choice. After all, it doesn’t always have to be about contrast or high resolution. Sometimes a black strap looks best with a black watch, and in this case, a brown strap looks best with a brown watch. I like having the choice, which is why I own more watch straps than watches. I’ll ask Knud what the chances are that we’ll get a brown textile or Alcantara strap.


Last but not least: a wild mix

To wrap things up, I’d like to show you a few outfits that I particularly liked. The denim strap on my Galo Novo Cruisin is still a prototype and isn’t available for order yet. At first, I was skeptical because I don’t even wear jeans that often. But when I saw this outfit, I started looking forward to next summer. The Galo, the jeans, the white T-shirt, and the denim strap look really cool together. With my Rolex Datejust, I broke two rules at once, but I love it. The first is the rule I mentioned earlier: you shouldn’t mix black and brown. I do wonder, though, why it looks so damn good. The second rule seems to be that you’re not supposed to wear Rolex watches on leather straps unless they’re ancient and were already vintage back when “neo-vintage” wasn’t even a thing yet. But even there, I have to ask: Why shouldn’t I do that if I already have a watch whose design has changed only slightly since 1945? The Novonappa from Strapklub seems tailor-made for this. It’s so soft and feels incredibly high-quality. No wonder—as far as I know, it’s the same leather that Hermès uses.

I rarely wear the Sternglas Hamburg because it’s a bit too big for me. But the combination of the green dial, bronze case, and green calfskin strap is really great. On the DUG Purist, I tried the Cordovan leather, since it’s considered the most durable. The brown is still a bit too bright for my taste right now, but cordovan leather changes color in a very beautiful way as you wear it. I often wear the DUG with a brown suede strap, but that one is a bit too thin for me. The thickness of this strap seems perfect to me. Cordovan is always a bit stiff at first, but it quickly becomes supple. For the Casio A168WA-3AY, I first had to get an 18–20 mm adapter because the 18 mm strap looks too small and would be too thin to fit the watch. But the contrast between the watch’s gray-green face and the orange cowhide leather is really cool.


Pay attention to the quality of your watch straps

Watch straps are a world of their own. After all, you get your watch with a strap to begin with. But as mentioned earlier, that might not be the best fit for you, your wrist, or the way you plan to wear the watch. So your first instinct is probably to look for a different strap from the same brand. However, you’ll usually end up paying a hefty premium—which isn’t necessary. For example, I love Nomos straps, but most don’t have a quick-release buckle, which makes changing them in the morning too fiddly for me. But some brands charge exorbitant prices for standard straps. Omega, for instance, charges 300 euros for a calfskin strap. I’ve held it in my hand: It’s definitely no better than the standard strap from StrapKlub that I tested here, which costs less than a third of that. The Novonappa calfskin strap costs only half as much, but in my opinion, it’s much better than Omega’s. If you have the right clasp and know what lug width you need, then you don’t have to buy the original and pay extra.

But be careful with the opposite extreme as well—that is, with offers that are way too cheap, which you see all over the internet. There’s a lot of junk out there, and you won’t get a good watch strap for 12 euros. Keep in mind: If the strap breaks, you might lose your watch. I’d rather spend a few euros more. It doesn’t have to be Novonappa right away. At the beginning of my “watch journey,” I definitely bought watch straps on Amazon, Temu, and AliExpress, and I regret every single purchase. I’m not saying that only junk is sold there. There are also some brands that offer decent quality. The problem, however, is that the pictures often look very professional, but the strap practically falls apart when it arrives at your home. Watch straps are no different from other clothing items in this regard. Material and craftsmanship are crucial to quality, and good leather isn’t worth much if it’s poorly sewn. Maybe I’ll test out a few straps from Amazon, Temu, and AliExpress sometime. The problem is that they keep popping up under new brand names, so I’m not sure if it’s worth the effort.

Between these two extremes, there are some really great providers. Strapklub positions itself as a high-quality alternative at reasonable prices. The quality is at least on par with most straps from major brands, but you pay significantly less. You won’t find the stitching, the super-soft Zermatt inner leather, and the full-wrap construction at these prices with most other providers. I especially appreciate that the Strapklub website lists both the upper and lower materials for each strap, as well as how much handwork went into it. That way, you can decide for yourself which strap is a better fit.


Conclusion: How to Find the Right Watch Band

I’ve written quite a bit now about my personal taste, my watches, and the material, but I still haven’t explicitly answered the question posed in this article. And that was exactly my intention with this article. I can’t tell you which material looks best on your wrist, feels best, or which color goes best with which watch. Strapklub has a few style guides, but they’re really just meant to serve as inspiration. If you really like the strap that came with your watch, then maybe you don’t need a different one at all. Whatever you like is what’s best. In any case, I really enjoy switching out my straps every now and then, and I love how much it can change the look of a watch.

With that in mind, I hope I’ve given you some ideas. Since not everyone has friends who’ve just started a watch strap brand, head to your nearest jewellery store or even a department store and figure out what you like. Think about which material, color, and length suit you best. The standard size is way too long for most wrists. Also check out Reddit or Instagram for watch inspiration—you’re sure to find plenty of great ideas there. Once you know what you want, give Strapklub a try. Or check out one of the many other great providers of quality watch straps, such as Wristbuddys, Delugs, Hirsch, Kaufmann, or Fluco. In my opinion, Strapklub holds its own against the established brands. I’m really impressed by the quality, the variety, and the classic and modern colors. You’ll definitely see some of my watches with Strapklub straps on Instagram in the future.


Disclaimer

I know Knud and Toni, the two founders of Strapklub, personally, and that’s how we got in touch. I didn’t receive any money for this article; rather, I’m genuinely enthusiastic about Strapklub’s products, which is why I reached out to Knud and asked him if I could borrow some items. I already own quite a few watch straps and could have written this article using my own, but I don’t have that many different colors—I’ve mostly stuck with the boring ones so far. I really enjoyed doing this review, so I’d be happy to do the same for other brands—as long as I can share my honest opinion. I’ll definitely be keeping the Novonappa and the orange cowhide strap, if only because I’ve already scratched them—I didn’t realize the sharp edge on the steel bracelet of my Rolex was there. I’ll definitely buy the ice-blue Alcantara as well, but I’ll wait until I can get it in my size, because the end is thicker than on the thinner leather straps. I also think the black fabric strap is great, especially for swimming. I might even write a separate article about that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Uhrenrekursion (EN)
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.